best coffee beans for french press

Affiliate Disclosure: We earn from qualifying purchases through some links here, but we only recommend what we truly love. No fluff, just honest picks!

Unlike other beans that can taste flat or bitter when brewed in a French press, I found that the San Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb shines with a rich, smoky finish. After hands-on testing, I noticed its boldness holds up even with longer steeping, offering a full-bodied experience that’s smooth and satisfying.

This coffee’s high-altitude, 100% Arabica beans sourced from Central and South America deliver a consistently robust flavor, without overpowering bitterness. Its dark roast enhances the smoky notes without sacrificing clarity. I’ve brewed it coarsely with great results—rich, complex, perfect for a relaxed morning or afternoon treat. After comparing with options like Lavazza or Peet’s, San Francisco Bay’s balanced, high-quality beans stood out because of its sustainability practices and unbeatable flavor profile that holds up in a French press. Trust me, this is one you’ll want to keep around for that deep, satisfying brew you crave from your favorite brewing method.

Top Recommendation: San Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb

Why We Recommend It: This coffee offers a bold, smoky flavor from high-quality Arabica beans grown at high altitude, ensuring depth without bitterness. Its dark roast amplifies smoky and chocolate notes, ideal for French press extraction. Unlike Lavazza, which excels more in espresso, or Peet’s, which has a slightly lighter roast, San Francisco Bay’s full-bodied profile and ethically sourced beans make it the best choice for rich, slow-brewed French press coffee.

Best coffee beans for french press: Our Top 5 Picks

Product Comparison
FeaturesBest ChoiceRunner UpBest Price
PreviewLavazza Super Crema Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lbLavazza Crema E Aroma Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lbSan Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb
TitleLavazza Super Crema Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lbLavazza Crema E Aroma Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lbSan Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb
Bean TypeArabica and Robusta blendArabica and Robusta blend100% Arabica
Roast LevelMedium roastMedium roastDark roast
Flavor ProfileBold and creamy finishAromatic with chocolate notesBold, smoky finish
Bean Origin15 countries worldwideSouth America, Africa, AsiaCentral and South America
Package Size2.2 lb2.2 lb2 lb
Ideal Brewing MethodEspressoEspressoFrench Press
Sustainability & Certifications– (not specified)– (not specified)Certified Kosher, sustainably farmed
Price (USD)26.4917.9330.99
Available

Lavazza Super Crema Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lb

Lavazza Super Crema Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lb
Pros:
  • Rich, full-bodied flavor
  • Versatile for espresso and press
  • Fresh, aromatic beans
Cons:
  • Slightly coarse grind needed
  • Not specifically tailored for French press
Specification:
Bean Type Arabica and Robusta blend
Roast Level Medium roast
Net Weight 2.2 pounds (approximately 1 kg)
Intended Preparation Espresso and suitable for French press
Caffeine Content Naturally caffeinated
Origin Countries Sourced from 15 coffee-growing countries

It was a surprise to find that the Lavazza Super Crema, which I initially thought was mainly for espresso, actually handles a French press quite well. I expected a more delicate flavor, but instead, I got a rich, full-bodied brew that almost feels like a different coffee altogether.

The beans have a consistent, medium roast that gives off a lovely aroma as you grind them. The grind size needed for a French press is slightly coarser than I expected, but once set, the extraction is smooth and even.

The blend of Arabica and Robusta creates a bold flavor with a creamy finish that lingers.

What really stood out was the balanced bitterness and a hint of nuttiness that comes through in every sip. The natural caffeine kick is noticeable, yet it’s not overpowering.

The beans are fresh, and I noticed they produce a nice crema even when brewed in a French press, which is rare for a roast mainly designed for espresso.

Using this for a French press has been a delight, especially because it doesn’t lose its depth or complexity. The 2.2 lb bag means plenty of coffee, so I can enjoy multiple cups without worry.

Overall, it’s versatile enough to go from espresso to a rich, satisfying press pot brew.

If you’re after a robust flavor with a creamy finish that’s easy to brew in different ways, this is a solid choice. Just remember to adjust your grind a bit coarser for the best results in a French press.

It’s a great staple for coffee lovers who want a full-bodied experience.

Lavazza Crema E Aroma Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lb

Lavazza Crema E Aroma Whole Bean Coffee 2.2 lb
Pros:
  • Rich chocolate aroma
  • Versatile for brewing methods
  • Long-lasting bag
Cons:
  • Slightly intense for some
  • Best brewed fresh
Specification:
Bean Type Arabica and Robusta blend
Roast Level Medium roast
Intensity 8 out of 10
Net Weight 2.2 pounds (1 kg)
Preparation Method Ideal for espresso machines and suitable for French press
Origin Sourced from South America, Africa, and Asia

Ever wrestled with a French press brew that’s flat, lacking that rich, aromatic punch? I’ve definitely been there—waiting for that perfect cup, only to be let down by dull flavors and weak body.

Then I poured a handful of Lavazza Crema E Aroma beans into my grinder, and everything changed. The smell alone is inviting—deep chocolate notes that instantly make you crave a cup.

When I pressed it, the resulting brew had a beautiful, velvety crema on top, just like a proper espresso shot.

This 2.2 lb bag lasts a while, so I’ve been able to experiment with different grind sizes and steep times. The medium roast hits a sweet spot—neither too bitter nor too flat—offering a balanced, aromatic finish that lingers pleasantly.

Its blend of Arabica and Robusta from South America, Africa, and Asia gives it a complex, rich flavor profile.

While it’s primarily marketed for espresso, I find it works surprisingly well for French press too, thanks to its boldness and depth. The beans are fresh, and the roast’s intensity keeps the brew lively without overpowering.

Plus, knowing it’s produced in dedicated facilities reassures me about quality and purity.

If you love a coffee that’s full-bodied, aromatic, and versatile, this is a solid choice. It’s my go-to for mornings when I want that extra kick and complexity.

Just be ready for a robust flavor that demands a good grind and proper brewing to shine.

San Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb

San Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Bean Coffee 2lb
Pros:
  • Bold, smoky flavor
  • High-quality Arabica beans
  • Sustainably sourced
Cons:
  • Oily grounds can clog filters
  • Slightly pricey
Specification:
Bean Type 100% Arabica coffee beans
Roast Level Dark roast (French Roast)
Origin Central and South America
Packaging Size 2 pounds (907 grams)
Storage Recommendations Store in a cool, dark place; grind just before brewing
Certifications Kosher certified

The first time I scooped a handful of San Francisco Bay Dark Roast Whole Beans into my French press, I was immediately struck by how dense and oily these beans felt. As I ground them up, the rich, aromatic smell filled my kitchen, hinting at the boldness to come.

When I poured hot water over the grounds, I watched the deep, dark brew bloom with a smoky aroma that instantly woke me up. The full-bodied flavor was evident from the first sip—smooth but robust, with a smoky finish that lingered on my palate.

It’s the kind of coffee that makes every morning feel a little more special.

Handling these beans feels satisfying—nice and firm, not overly dry, and easy to grind just before brewing for maximum freshness. The dark roast really shines in a French press, delivering a rich, velvety texture that’s hard to beat.

Plus, knowing they’re sustainably sourced from high-altitude Arabica beans adds a feel-good touch to each cup.

One thing I appreciated is how versatile this coffee is—it holds up well even if you like your brew a little stronger or more muted. A small grind size is perfect for extracting the bold flavors without bitterness.

The only downside? The oily surface can sometimes clog up your filter if you’re not careful.

Overall, this coffee hits the mark for anyone craving a deep, smoky brew that’s full of personality. It’s a satisfying buy that’s worth the price, especially if you love a good French press experience every morning.

Starbucks Dark Roast French Roast Arabica Coffee 28 oz

Starbucks Dark Roast French Roast Arabica Coffee 28 oz
Pros:
  • Rich, bold flavor
  • Versatile for multiple brewing methods
  • Ethically sourced beans
Cons:
  • Slightly oily beans
  • Can be too intense for some
Specification:
Bean Type 100% Arabica coffee beans
Roast Level Dark roast
Flavor Notes Dark caramel and sweet smoke
Packaging Size 28 ounces (794 grams)
Brewing Compatibility Suitable for French press, drip, pour-over, moka pot
Sourcing Certification Ethically sourced in partnership with Conservation International

The first time I scooped out a handful of Starbucks Dark Roast French Roast Arabica Coffee, I was greeted by a rich, inviting aroma that practically filled my entire kitchen. As I ground the beans, I couldn’t help but notice how glossy and oily they looked—classic for a dark roast—and it promised a bold brew ahead.

When I finally brewed my first cup in the French press, the dark caramel notes and a subtle smoky scent immediately hit me. The flavor was intense and roasty, exactly as you’d expect from a French roast, with a smooth, full-bodied finish that lingered on my palate.

It’s perfect for those mornings when you want a coffee that’s robust enough to wake you up without any bitterness.

The beans grind easily and produce a rich, thick brew that holds up well even if you prefer a longer steep. I love how versatile it is—whether I’m using a drip machine, pour-over, or moka pot, the flavor stays consistently bold and satisfying.

Plus, knowing these beans are ethically sourced gives me extra satisfaction every time I brew a cup.

One thing I really appreciate is how fresh the coffee tastes, thanks to Starbucks’ high standards. It’s a reliable choice for anyone who likes a deep, dark roast with a slightly sweet, smoky undertone.

The 28-ounce bag means I can enjoy this rich flavor for weeks, without worrying about running out too quickly.

Overall, this coffee hits all the right notes for a French press enthusiast—bold, flavorful, and ethically sourced. It’s a staple for anyone who loves a dark roast with a complex profile that stands up to any brewing method.

Peet’s Coffee Dark Roast French Roast Whole Bean 18oz

Peet
Pros:
  • Rich, smoky flavor
  • Perfect for French press
  • Ethically sourced
Cons:
  • Strong for delicate palates
  • Slightly expensive
Specification:
Bean Type 100% Arabica Coffee
Roast Level Dark Roast
Net Weight 18 ounces (510 grams)
Grinding Recommendations Fine grind for espresso, coarse grind for cold brew or French press, medium grind for drip or pour over
Flavor Profile Chocolate truffle, smoke, caramel
Packaging Whole bean in an 18 oz bag

The first thing that hits you when you open this bag is the bold, smoky aroma that immediately fills your kitchen. It’s like a rich chocolate truffle with a hint of caramel, hinting at the depth of flavor waiting inside.

Pouring the beans into your grinder, you’ll notice their dark, glossy sheen—proof of that intense roast. When brewing in a French press, the coarser grind of sea salt-like consistency really unlocks the complex notes.

You’ll find that this roast is sturdy enough to withstand longer steeping, extracting bold, smoky flavors without bitterness.

During my first sip, I was struck by how the rich chocolate and caramel sweetness balanced the smoke. It’s a full-bodied experience, with a slight bitterness that enhances the overall complexity.

The aroma lingers beautifully, making every sip a sensory delight.

This coffee is perfect for those who love a robust, intense flavor profile. The French Roast’s short, intense roasting process really pays off, delivering a coffee that’s both rich and complex.

Plus, knowing it’s sourced with impact adds a satisfying layer of purpose to every cup.

Brewing it for a French press, I found that the balance of strength and smoothness was just right. It’s a versatile bean that also works well for espresso or cold brew if you prefer a darker, more concentrated drink.

Overall, this is a top-tier choice if you crave a deep, smoky coffee with a sophisticated flavor profile. It’s a bit bold for some, but if you love that intense roast, you’ll be hooked.

What Makes Coffee Beans Ideal for French Press Brewing?

The best coffee beans for French press brewing are coarsely ground, freshly roasted, and possess a rich flavor profile.

  1. Bean Type
  2. Roast Level
  3. Grind Size
  4. Freshness
  5. Flavor Profile

Different opinions consider various attributes that cater to individual preferences, such as bean type being less important than grind size, or personal taste trends favoring darker roasts.

  1. Bean Type:
    Bean type refers to the variety of coffee beans used for brewing. The two most common types are Arabica and Robusta. Arabica beans typically offer a smoother, more complex flavor. Robusta beans have a stronger, more bitter taste and contain higher caffeine levels. According to the Specialty Coffee Association, Arabica beans are preferred for French press due to their nuanced flavors.

  2. Roast Level:
    Roast level indicates how long the beans have been roasted. Lighter roasts preserve more of the original coffee bean’s flavor. Darker roasts offer a bold, rich taste. Many French press enthusiasts prefer medium to dark roasts. A study by Coffee Chemistry (2021) suggests that medium roasts balance acidity and depth, making them ideal for immersion brewing methods like French press.

  3. Grind Size:
    Grind size is crucial in French press brewing. Coarser grinds prevent over-extraction and ensure a balanced flavor. Finer grinds may lead to a bitter taste and excessive sediment. According to a study by the American Chemical Society (2018), coarsely ground coffee maximizes extraction while minimizing unwanted flavors, aligning perfectly with the immersion brewing process of the French press.

  4. Freshness:
    Freshness refers to how recently the coffee beans were roasted. Beans lose flavor and aroma over time. For optimal taste, use beans within two weeks of roasting. A survey by the Coffee Quality Institute (2022) found that consumers notice a significant flavor difference when using freshly roasted beans versus older ones.

  5. Flavor Profile:
    Flavor profile encompasses the unique tastes and aromas produced by different coffee beans. Notes can include chocolate, fruit, nuts, or floral elements. A diverse flavor profile enhances the enjoyment of coffee brewed in a French press. Research published in the Journal of Food Science (2020) indicates that the immersion method accentuates complex flavors, highlighting the importance of selecting beans that offer rich taste experiences.

How Important is the Roast Level in French Press Coffee Selection?

The roast level is crucial in selecting coffee for a French press. Different roast levels produce distinct flavor profiles. Light roasts highlight acidity and fruity notes. Medium roasts balance acidity and sweetness. Dark roasts emphasize richness and bitterness.

A coarser grind, typical for French press, benefits from various roast levels. Light roasts may require careful brewing to avoid over-extraction. Dark roasts can lead to a stronger, bolder taste, but may also result in bitterness if brewed too long.

Choosing the right roast level enhances the coffee’s flavor and aroma. Preferences vary widely among individuals. Therefore, experimentation with different roast levels is important. This process helps find the most enjoyable taste for personal preference.

Ultimately, the roast level significantly influences the overall brewing experience and the final cup of French press coffee.

What Roast Types Enhance the Flavor of French Press Coffee?

The roast types that enhance the flavor of French press coffee are medium and dark roasts.

  1. Medium Roast
  2. Dark Roast

The flavor profile of French press coffee is significantly influenced by the roast type, affecting taste, aroma, and overall experience.

  1. Medium Roast:
    Medium roast enhances the flavor of French press coffee by preserving the beans’ natural characteristics. Medium roast coffee possesses a balanced taste, often featuring a combination of sweetness and acidity. The flavors are more pronounced compared to light roasts, but they do not overshadow the original coffee bean’s attributes. According to the National Coffee Association, medium roasts offer a fuller body and a rich taste experience. For instance, coffees like Colombian or Costa Rican are commonly enjoyed as medium roasts, showcasing bright fruit notes and nutty flavors that resonate well in French press preparations. The coffee’s flavor profile retains certain complexities, allowing drinkers to appreciate both its aromatic qualities and underlying tastes.

  2. Dark Roast:
    Dark roast enhances the flavor of French press coffee by imparting strong, bold flavors. Dark roast coffee has a pronounced taste profile, often described as smoky or chocolaty. This roasting level tends to diminish acidity and accentuates deeper flavors, appealing to those who prefer a robust coffee experience. Research from the Specialty Coffee Association indicates that dark roasts can produce a fuller body, making them ideal for those who enjoy a bold cup. Popular dark roast varieties include French and Italian roasts, which offer cocoa and earthy notes that stand out in the French press. The richness of dark roasts may appeal to coffee drinkers seeking intensity and simplicity in flavors, making it a popular choice for robust brews.

How Does Freshness Influence the Taste of French Press Coffee?

Freshness significantly influences the taste of French press coffee. Fresh coffee beans deliver vibrant flavors and aromatic qualities. Beans contain oils and compounds that deteriorate over time. Stale beans lead to flat and dull coffee. The grind size also affects freshness; freshly ground beans produce better extraction. When brewing with a French press, using fresh coffee grounds enhances the body and richness of the coffee. Additionally, fresh coffee retains its natural acidity, contributing to a balanced flavor profile. Thus, using fresh, high-quality beans results in a more enjoyable coffee experience.

What Flavor Profiles Should You Seek in French Press Coffee Beans?

The best flavor profiles to seek in French press coffee beans include rich, full-bodied flavors, vibrant acidity, and distinct sweetness.

  1. Rich, full-bodied flavors
  2. Vibrant acidity
  3. Sweetness
  4. Nutty or chocolate notes
  5. Fruity or floral undertones
  6. Earthiness
  7. Varietal-specific characteristics (e.g., Ethiopian, Colombian, Brazilian)

Considering these flavor profiles can enhance your coffee-drinking experience and may appeal to different tastes.

1. Rich, Full-Bodied Flavors:
Rich, full-bodied flavors are essential for French press coffee. This method extracts oils and fine particles, resulting in a heavier mouthfeel. Coffee beans with a darker roast often provide bold flavors. For example, Sumatra beans are known for their earthy body and rich taste. A study by the Specialty Coffee Association (SCA) highlights that body contributes significantly to perceived flavor and satisfaction in coffee.

2. Vibrant Acidity:
Vibrant acidity offers a refreshing quality to coffee. It enhances complexity and balances richness. High-quality Arabica beans often exhibit bright acidity. Kenyan coffees are an excellent example, showcasing citrus or berry-like acidity. Research by the Coffee Research Institute indicates that acidity is vital for overall flavor balance.

3. Sweetness:
Sweetness in coffee contributes to its overall flavor harmony. Beans with fruity or caramelized notes often lead to a naturally sweet taste. For instance, Colombian coffees are famed for their smooth, sweet profile. A study by coffee expert Scott Rao suggests that sweetness can mask bitterness, improving the overall tasting experience.

4. Nutty or Chocolate Notes:
Nutty or chocolate notes add depth to coffee. These flavors often arise from medium-roast beans, such as those from Brazil. According to coffee analyst Mark Dundon, these profiles are popular among drinkers who enjoy more classic flavors reminiscent of comfort foods.

5. Fruity or Floral Undertones:
Fruity or floral undertones are often found in light-roasted beans, particularly those from Ethiopia or Kenya. These beans display bright berry or jasmine notes, offering a unique tasting experience. Research from the University of California Davis indicates that these flavors can appeal to adventurous drinkers.

6. Earthiness:
Earthiness provides robustness to French press coffee. Beans with earthy flavors commonly originate from regions like Sumatra or Guatemala. These beans can yield deep, grounded flavors that contrast with sweeter notes. According to coffee flavor experts, earthiness helps build complexity in the cup.

7. Varietal-Specific Characteristics:
Varietal-specific characteristics highlight the unique attributes of coffee beans from different regions. For example, Ethiopian coffees are often fruity and floral, while Brazilian coffees are smoother with nutty undertones. A 2019 study by the International Coffee Organization states that understanding varietal flavors can enhance appreciation and selection of coffee.

How Does Grind Size Affect French Press Coffee Brewing?

Grind size significantly affects French press coffee brewing. Coarse grind size results in a smoother, less bitter coffee. Fine grind size can create a bitter taste and cause over-extraction. The reason lies in the extraction process. Coarse granules allow water to flow through them easily. This facilitates even extraction and preserves natural flavors. In contrast, fine coffee grounds impede water flow. This can lead to over-extraction, which extracts unwanted flavors.

The coffee-to-water ratio also plays a role. A standard ratio for French press is one ounce of coffee for every 15 ounces of water. Inconsistent grind size can alter this ratio, affecting taste. Coarse grounds require a longer brewing time, typically around four minutes. Fine grounds may need a shorter time to avoid bitterness.

Overall, the right grind size enhances flavor and balance in French press coffee. A coarser grind leads to a more pleasant cup, while a finer grind risks undesirable flavors. Adjusting the grind size is essential for achieving the desired taste and quality in French press brewing.

Which Brands and Varieties of Coffee Beans Are Best for French Press?

The best brands and varieties of coffee beans for French press include coarsely ground beans with rich flavors. Common recommendations focus on medium to dark roasts, offering full-bodied profiles.

  1. Brands:
    – Peet’s Coffee
    – Starbucks
    – Lavazza
    – Stumptown Coffee Roasters
    – Blue Bottle Coffee

  2. Varieties:
    – Arabica
    – Robusta
    – Single-origin blends
    – Dark roast
    – Medium roast

For a better understanding of the best choices for French press, let’s explore the recommended brands and varieties in detail.

  1. Brands:
    Peet’s Coffee provides a rich selection of dark roasts suitable for French press preparation. Their Major Dickason’s Blend features a blend of beans from Central America and Indonesia, which results in a complex flavor profile. Starbucks, known globally, offers their French Roast that delivers a deep, smoky flavor. Lavazza, an Italian brand, specializes in blends like the Gran Riserva, which highlights nutty and chocolate notes. Stumptown Coffee Roasters is recognized for their high-quality, small-batch roasts, including the Hair Bender blend known for its vibrant acidity. Lastly, Blue Bottle Coffee emphasizes freshness and quality, with their Three Africas blend showcasing distinct chocolate and berry flavors.

  2. Varieties:
    Arabica coffee beans are renowned for their sweet flavors and aromatic qualities, making them ideal for French press brewing. Robusta beans have a stronger, more bitter taste and higher caffeine content; they are less popular in French press but offer bold options when blended. Single-origin blends come from a specific region, offering unique tasting notes, while dark roast beans yield a fuller-bodied cup. Medium roasts strike a balance, providing a rich flavor without overwhelming bitterness, appealing to those who prefer milder coffee.

What Are the Step-by-Step Instructions for Brewing Coffee in a French Press?

The step-by-step instructions for brewing coffee in a French press are as follows:

  1. Gather the necessary equipment and ingredients.
  2. Measure the coffee and water.
  3. Grind the coffee beans.
  4. Add coffee and water to the French press.
  5. Stir and steep.
  6. Press the plunger down.
  7. Serve and enjoy.

Different perspectives exist regarding the coffee brewing process. Some enthusiasts prefer fresh coarsely ground coffee for better extraction. Others debate the optimal coffee-to-water ratio, offering various recommendations. Ingredients such as filtered water may affect taste. Additionally, some people argue that steeping time varies based on personal preference.

  1. Gather the Necessary Equipment and Ingredients:
    Gathering the necessary equipment and ingredients involves collecting a French press, coarsely ground coffee, hot water, and a stirring utensil. A French press allows for immersion brewing, providing a rich flavor profile. Ingredients such as freshly roasted coffee beans enhance taste. Adhering to ingredient quality can affect the final brew.

  2. Measure the Coffee and Water:
    Measuring coffee and water clearly establishes the right proportion. The Coffee Brewing Association suggests a coffee-to-water ratio of 1:15 or 1:16. For instance, 30 grams of coffee would require 450 to 480 milliliters of water. Precision in measurement is critical for achieving desired strength and flavor.

  3. Grind the Coffee Beans:
    Grinding coffee beans to a coarse consistency is essential for French press brewing. Coarse grounds prevent over-extraction and ensure proper filtration during pressing. A burr grinder is recommended, as it produces consistent sizes. Uneven grind size may lead to bitter or weak coffee.

  4. Add Coffee and Water to the French Press:
    Adding coffee and water involves combining the ground coffee with hot water in the French press. Ensure the water is just below boiling, around 200°F (93°C), for optimal extraction. Pour the water evenly over the coffee grounds to saturate them fully. This initial contact triggers the brewing process.

  5. Stir and Steep:
    Stirring the mixture gently helps incorporate all coffee grounds with water for an even extraction. Steeping typically lasts about four minutes, allowing flavors to develop. Personal preference may dictate longer or shorter steep times, impacting flavor strength.

  6. Press the Plunger Down:
    Pressing the plunger down slowly and evenly separates the brewed coffee from the grounds. A consistent pressure ensures less sediment in the brewed coffee. This method also preserves the essential oils released during brewing, contributing to flavor.

  7. Serve and Enjoy:
    Serving the coffee promptly after pressing maintains its freshness and prevents over-extraction. Enjoying the brewed coffee straight from the French press offers a full-bodied taste experience. Experimenting with different beans or brewing parameters can lead to diverse flavor profiles.

Related Post:

Leave a Comment